Scam refund
A bank can no longer send a scam victim to court to get the money back.
In its judgment of 15 October 2026 in Case C-70/25, the First Chamber of the Court of Justice of the European Union held that “a payment service provider cannot refuse to refund immediately to a payer the amount of an unauthorised payment transaction on the ground that that payer made that transaction possible through gross negligence, in breach of his or her obligations under Article 69 of Directive 2015/2366.” The question came from the District Court in Koszalin, Poland.
Your case is different? Ask an expert
First consultation is free. We keep your details private.
The Koszalin case
A bank customer in Poland put an item up for sale on an online auction platform. A would-be buyer sent a link that appeared to confirm the sale and led to a copy of the bank's website, where she entered her online banking login.
The fraudster moved PLN 3,000, about EUR 705, out of the account with an SMS code obtained from her by the same deceit. She reported the payment to the bank and the police the next day. The bank refused the refund, citing gross negligence.
Refund by the next business day
Article 73(1) of the EU Payment Services Directive obliges the bank to refund an unauthorised payment immediately, and no later than the end of the following business day after it notes or is notified of the transaction. The account is restored to the state it would have been in without the payment, with a credit value date no later than the debit date.
The court held that the article provides for “only one exception to the immediate refund obligation, namely the situation where the payment service provider has reasonable grounds for suspecting fraud and communicates those grounds to the relevant national authority in writing.”
Your case is different? Ask an expert
First consultation is free. We keep your details private.
The bank carries the burden of proof
Under the judgment, “Article 72(2) of Directive 2015/2366 places on the payment service provider the burden of proving gross negligence on the part of the payer.”
The opposite reading would have left customers to go to court and bear the costs of the proceedings. The court found that difficult to reconcile with a high level of consumer protection. A bank that considers a customer grossly negligent can claim the losses back only after it has made the refund.
A EUR 50 ceiling
The preamble of the directive, cited in the judgment, states that “the user should be liable only for a very limited amount, unless the payment service user has acted fraudulently or with gross negligence. In that context, an amount of EUR 50 seems to be adequate in order to ensure a harmonised and high-level user protection within the Union.”
Once the customer has told the bank that a card or login may be compromised, further losses from its use stay with the bank.
We will open an account with a bank in the EU
Murblz experts pick a bank that works with your country of residence and your income, prepare the file so the bank opens the account the first time and stay with you until the card is in your hands.
Details and the cost are available on request from a manager in the chat: the calculation takes into account the country, the bank and your case.
Fraud cases across Europe
Payment fraud cases and the way European banks handle refund claims are examined in a detailed analysis by Finflags, the banking and fintech publication.
The judgment binds the courts of every EU member state, and Murblz experts open personal accounts with banks across the Union. Countries and banks are listed on our personal accounts page.
FAQ
Does the scam refund rule cover cards and online banking?
How long does a customer have to report a scam payment?
Don’t want to figure this out alone?
We handle the whole process end to end: we check your documents, match a program to your situation and give you honest timelines and costs. Ask your question in the chat: the free consultation starts right here. Legal representation before authorities and courts is handled by Murblz specialists together with locally licensed partners.
The Murblz consultant replies straight away in the chat on this page. Describe your situation and we will work it out together.
Get a free review of my caseWhat happens next
- An expert reviews your situation and goal.
- We contact you the way you prefer and answer your questions.
- You get a work plan, honest timelines and a written quote.